HOT Lanes - Non-Rush Hour Nightmare?
Printed From: Slug-Lines.com
Category: Archived Slugging Topics
Forum Name: HOT Lanes Discussion
Forum Description: Post messages regarding High Occupancy Toll (HOT) lanes here.
URL: http://www.slug-lines.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=2931
Printed Date: 25 Nov 2024 at 3:48pm
Software Version: Web Wiz Forums 11.10 - http://www.webwizforums.com
Topic: HOT Lanes - Non-Rush Hour Nightmare?
Posted By: Bob
Subject: HOT Lanes - Non-Rush Hour Nightmare?
Date Posted: 18 Sep 2006 at 11:24am
There has been little discussion on this board about the impact of HOT on non-rush hour times. Especially evenings and weekends. Here's the scenario I was thinking about over the weekend. Current situation ---It is 6pm on a weekday. Normally, a massive wave of SOVs heads for the HOV lane because it is opened to them. That lightens the load on the regular lanes.
Flash forward to 2009. It is 6pm. Tolls for SOVs are 24/7. Only one-third of the regular SOV crowd opts to pay the $12 it will cost to get home. Result--a MASSIVE jam in the regular lanes.
|
Replies:
Posted By: N_or_S_bound
Date Posted: 18 Sep 2006 at 11:37am
It's probably been said before, but I'll ask it just to stimulate this thread some:
Are the HOT prices going to be dependent on usage? Or is there just a set fee per mile period?
One would think that non-peak hours would receive a reduced price to encourage usage.
Supply and demand.
NoSb
SOV because you can, HOV because you care!
|
Posted By: Bob
Date Posted: 18 Sep 2006 at 11:47am
|
It's going to be changeable or dynamic. But the point I am making is that, almost no matter what it is, the traffic in the non-HOT lanes will be much worse during non-rush because of those who previously took the free HOV lanes will be in the regular lanes. I put forth the proposition that dynamic tolling has severe limitations. Another point is that the HOT company has the goal of maximizing profit. This may in many cases not correspond with maximizing overall corridor throughput. For example, if profit is maximized at $1.00 per mile, do you think Fluor will reduce the toll just to improve the regular lanes?
|
Posted By: N_or_S_bound
Date Posted: 18 Sep 2006 at 12:06pm
Don't think they will reduce the toll "just to improve the regular lanes", BUT they WILL reduce the tolls to pick up some business if their HOT lanes are sitting there idle.
They're already paying folks to man it, the roads are already there, why wouldn't they try to grab business with dynamic tolls (a la Kmart blue light special)?
Doesn't make sense to not attract vehicles when there's plenty available and at some price, some will pay.
NoSb
SOV because you can, HOV because you care!
|
Posted By: Bob
Date Posted: 18 Sep 2006 at 12:41pm
As an example of why dynamic tolling wont work. The pro HOT crowd believes that a change in toll rate will result in an instant move in or out of the HOT lane. Wont happen. Reasons: heavy traffic, and limited entry exit points. Lets say its 6:30 pm and there is some extra capacity in the HOT lane. The toll is reduced from $1.00 to $.50 per mile. But, all those people stranded in the regular lane jam will take up to a half hour to make it to the entry point.
Dynamic tolling has a major time lag between toll change and traffic change.
|
Posted By: N_or_S_bound
Date Posted: 18 Sep 2006 at 1:19pm
Agreed, but you're looking at it from the point of a consumer.
From the point of the vendor, all they will want to do is utilize the capacity they have. They don't care about what it does for traffic flow outside the toll lanes. They just need to maximize cash flow in the toll lanes.
Look back at your couple responses. You're responding from the standpoint of the drivers. The toll road vendors could care less about congestion in the main lanes....except that it MAY drive business their way.
Note: I'm not taking any sides here. I'm just pointing out what the perspective of the vendor. The more packed the main lanes are, the better for business.
Oh, and the better for PERCEIVED customer satisfaction for those silly enough to drive 95/395 on the weekends.
NoSb
SOV because you can, HOV because you care!
|
Posted By: SpongeBob
Date Posted: 18 Sep 2006 at 1:26pm
That is why they have added all those new exits/entrances. It becomes possible for a driver to slip out of the regular lanes into the carpool lanes to get around bottlenecks, in Fluor's vision.
One new N-bound entrance in the plans is around Glebe, I think. Or closer in.
Anyway, imagine all the thousands of people in Arlandria getting on the toll road to cross the river. How high would you have to set the toll for that section to keep those people from totally congesting the lanes?
Dynamic tolling is the worst, least public-minded of all toll roads, since instead of it being budgeted for everyone to use (like the moderate toll on the Chesapeak Bypass to the OBX) it is designed from the beginning to force poor people off the toll lanes.
There is simply no other way to look at it.
|
Posted By: NoSUV
Date Posted: 18 Sep 2006 at 10:18pm
|
What's the toll for taking the bus?
|
Posted By: SpongeBob
Date Posted: 20 Sep 2006 at 10:24am
Right now, $3.80 vs. free to carpool.
Any more stupid questions?
|
Posted By: NoSUV
Date Posted: 20 Sep 2006 at 11:26am
|
So, the solution to having to pay a toll is to take the bus? Are you saying that taking 10 cars off of the express lanes is bad? For a cost that, if in a REAL carpool, would have to paid anyway?
|
Posted By: SpongeBob
Date Posted: 20 Sep 2006 at 1:25pm
|
Can someone explain what he means?
|
Posted By: slugjo
Date Posted: 20 Sep 2006 at 9:24pm
|
I think he means his feelings are hurt that slugs don't pay cash. I think he means that SOV hybrid is OK, HOV regular car is not, but HOV bus or locomotive is OK. And, I think he means we all should buy his brand of car, a perpetual motion machine that violates the second law of thermodynamics (I know, that's redundant).
|
Posted By: NoSUV
Date Posted: 21 Sep 2006 at 12:27pm
Using some rough calculations and the Joint Travel Regs:
If 30 mile commute, and 3 people per vehicle, and $.445 reimbursement per mile, then cost per person is $4.45.
Compare with Sponge's estimated toll cost of $38, or the cost of a bus ride of $3.80.
Toll roads are the solution. Pay the toll or get on the bus. Most will take the bus, and the cost is less than if slugs were paying their fair (fare) share.
|
Posted By: SpongeBob
Date Posted: 21 Sep 2006 at 3:02pm
Right. I see.
(Just BTW, it's not my estimate, it is the estimate of the Metropolitan Washington Council of Governments.)
So, NoSUV, are you planning on paying the toll or riding the bus?
|
Posted By: NoSUV
Date Posted: 21 Sep 2006 at 3:49pm
|